The major political parties' manifesto continue to roll. Labour grabbed the most attention yesterday, but Plaid Cymru also issued its manifesto, and I have taken a look.
Plaid Cymru breaks the pattern created by the other leading parties in this election, so far. They have not included a costing in their manifesto. Given that the whole basis of their approach to this election is to claim that the formula for apportioning UK-wide funding to Wales is inappropriate, I can understand why.
It is Plaid Cymru's suggestion that the Barnett formula, agreed upon decades ago but subject to occasional revision since, fails to take into consideration the varying needs of the countries in the UK, based in particular on the fact that the lower levels of average income in Wales are likely to result in higher levels of need for government services, and so an above average weighting for funds. The same problem exists in Scotland and is, of course, the basis on which the Tories claimed to undertake a levelling-up programme during the course of the last parliament, even though that turned out to be nothing more than a slush fund for redirecting money to Tory seats. I do, therefore, have considerable sympathy with the claim that Plaid Cymru make.
I also agree with many of the key proposals in their manifesto, which they summarise as follows:
On taxation, their key suggestions are:
It is hard to argue that these proposals would not be good for Wales when that would obviously be the case.
Many of these suggestions will be familiar to readers of this blog because it looks as though Plaid Cymru, like the Greens and the Liberal Democrats, have adopted many of the ideas in my Taxing Wealth Report 2024: some of the figures look remarkably similar. I cannot be sure what the relationship between that Report and those three manifestoes is, but the coincidences do appear high.
I was also pleased to see this on a Weslh Green New Deal:
PC does, in my opinion, play an important role in Welsh politics, even though it remains a minority party. It champions Wales and the Welsh language.
Unlike Labour, which dominates the Welsh scene, it is a party of ambition.
It is willing to promote the interests of the people it seeks to serve, and not vested interests.
Its role in promoting the opinion of those who live in West Wales in particular, which is an area for which I have a strong affection, is important, and from my conversations there, I realise that it is appreciated.
All that being said, Plaid Cymru, like the Greens, knows that it will only have a few members in the coming Parliament, at most. However, the fact that it rightly claims to be a part of ambition on the cover of its manifesto is reflected in the document that it has published. What a shame it is that the majority of the English lead parties in this election do not share that characteristic with Plaid Cymru. The country would be in a much better place if they did.
Plaid Cymru may not have presented detailed calculations in the manifesto, but I can still see why it will win support in at least some parts of Wales.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:
There is one thing that PC could do – make Community XXX a cornerstone of all action.
At the moment, the country is, as always, a place for extraction – was coal, now a combo of renewables and water. All of Wales could be powered by community and Welsh-gov owned renewables. The funding for this does not need to come from central gov for the simple reason that ALL renewable developments are heavily leveraged typically 80/20 debt equity. & the only question to answer on debt (with respect to renewables) is “who is the counterparty” – who is buying the energy (& households and businesses are quite good risks – mainly because the options for obtaining 24/7 elec/energy tend to be a bit limited). What is then left is organisation & getting permitting right. Technically, this is all trivial. Lining up the players (communities and the network operators) and getting things moving – very hard.
Excellent
Have you talked to them?
Not yet.
Need to get the “election” out of the way first.
(mostly connect with the gov in Cardiff which of course is Labour controlled)
I’m reading “King Copper: South Wales and the Copper Trade” at the moment. A well written book, fascinating to read. Where did that wealth go?
I agree on the closeness of Plaid Cymru and the Greens (Plaid Werdd), we talk to each other frequently and are close on policy.
The Welsh Greens are in favour of independence which is driven by a desire to rid Wales of the unrepresentative Westminster tribes. We’re also fed up of the elites sneering (David Cameron and Co), and denigrating us, never mentioning the many positives. In the past Welsh miners ‘Copper bottomed’ the navy to victory, powered the navy with coal and sent it sons to be slaughtered in unnecessary wars.
Thanks
Mike Parr: I tyeped “Community XXX” into a search engine brought me to (an unwanted) stack of pornographic videos. I am sure that this is not intended.
Most amusing. Of course by XXX I meant: energy, broadband, food, transport, help, pub/centre, this list is only limited by imagination & community need.